Kelly Smith, Crime Scene Tech
Smith is a crime scene technician in Santa Rosa County, Florida. She has taken crime scene classes, aquatic abuse death and homicidal drowning investigation classes in 2021, suicide investigation classes in 2022, a 40 hour class for basic crime scene investigation in 2019, and a crime scene processing class in 2020. She was a 911 dispatcher for 13 years prior to becoming a crime scene tech.
- Crime scene techs document, photograph, collect and package evidence, take fingerprints, and take DNA samples.
- On March 17, 2020 she was called to respond to the Escambia River Bridge for a report of a suitcase with a body in it.
- She responded to the east side of the bridge and was briefed on the situation by Detective Jason Yoder.
- Initially, Smith saw an olive green suitcase and material beside it, from a distance. The indentation nearby appeared to be where the suitcase had been dropped from the bridge.
- When she got closer to the suitcase she could tell she was looking at a blanket and a body. She photographed the scene.
- Exhibit 77 - 85 are photographs of the scene.
- E77 are the pylons to the bridge and the suitcase from a distance.
- E78 is the same thing from a different angle.
- E79 a closeup of the material and Gannon's body.
- E80 is a photo of the suitcase.
- She could tell that decomposition was already happening due to maggots and discoloration.
- E81 is looking down off the bridge to where the suitcase had been dropped.
- E82 is a closeup of the same view.
- E83 is a side view of the suitcase; one wheel is visible. A deep spot in the indentation is likely caused by the wheel.
- E84 is a photo of the inside of the suitcase. It was very wet inside.
- E85 is the back side of the suitcase, discolored from fluids.
- Smith attended Gannon's autopsy on March 18th at Sacred Heart Hospital in Pensacola.
- A tentative ID was made of Gannon Stauch.
- Exhibits 87, 88, 89 are evidence and photos of evidence.
- Exhibits 90 - 102 are photos from Gannon's autopsy.
- E87 is the bullet that was removed from Gannon's head.
- E88 is the bullet, I think in an envelope.
- E89 are red plastic pieces that Smith believes is part of the bullet.
- E90 is the pillow that was inside the suitcase; it's unclear immediately what caused a defect in the pillow.
- E91 is the other side of the pillow, it is wet and discolored. It had remnants of decomposition on it.
- E92 is an x-ray of the pillow; two projectiles are visible.
- E93 is a closeup of the damaged part of the pillowcase; potentially consistent with a bullet being fired into the pillow.
- E94 is a closeup of the defect of the pillow with the pillowcase off.
- E95 is a closeup of the bedding with a projectile.
- E96 is a closeup of the damage from the projectile.
- E97 is a projectile recovered from the pillow.
- E98 is a second defect in the pillowcase.
- E99 is a view of the defect with no pillowcase.
- E100 is a closer shot of the pillow.
- E101 is another view of the pillow with a cut made to get into the pillow.
- E102 is another projectile pulled out of the pillow.
- Exhibit 103 is both of the projectiles recovered from the pillow.
- Exhibits 104 - 120 are photos from Gannon's autopsy.
- Exhibit 104 was excluded as cumulative.
- Exhibit 105 is the T-shirt Gannon was wearing when they recovered him. There are defects on the shirt.
- Exhibit 106 is a closeup of the same defect on the shirt.
- Exhibit 107 is a closeup of another defect.
- E108 is another view of the same defect; the first two defects are on the lower left chest area.
- E109 is a defect in the left collarbone area.
- E110 is a closeup of the same image.
- E111 is the sleeve of the left arm.
- E112 is a closeup of the arm defect.
- E113 is the upper portion of the sleeve.
- E114 is a closer view of the upper sleeve.
- E115 is the other side of the shirt; this one is larger.
- E116 is a close up view.
- E117 is the back side of the left arm.
- E118 is a close up.
- E119 is further up the back side of the left sleeve.
- E120 is a close up view of the left sleeve.
- Exhibit 121 - 142 are photos of the jacket Gannon was wearing when they located him; admitted after sidebar.
- E121 is the lining of the jacket Gannon was wearing. There are at least five defects in the jacket.
- E122 is a closer view; it would coincide with the victim's back area.
- E123 is a closer view.
- E124 is a view of a defect in the lining.
- E125 is a closer view.
- E126 is a different defect.
- E127 is a closer view.
- E128 is a different defect; coinciding more with the back shoulder.
- E129 is a closer view.
- E130 is a different defect; closer to the top of the shoulder area.
- E131 is a closeup view.
- E132 is the hood of the jacket with some defects in it.
- E133 is a closer view of a defect.
- E134 is a closer view of a defect.
- E135 is a defect in the hood.
- E136 is a closer view of the defect.
- E137 is the back of the jacket.
- E138 is a defect.
- E139 is another defect.
- E140 is another defect.
- E141 is another defect in the back of the jacket.
- E142 is another defect closer to the zipper of the jacket.
- Exhibit 143 is a photo of the pants Gannon was wearing when they recovered his body
- E143 is a pair of jogging pants with a white stripe down the side of the legs. They are discolored.
- All of the items recovered from the suitcase including Gannon's clothing were covered in decomposition fluid. They brought photos instead of the items due to the smell.
- Exhibit 86 is the suitcase. They bring it toward the witness. We could see the size and shape but not the suitcase itself.
- It is an olive green suitcase, the one from the scene. It was collected from under the bridge.
- They carry the suitcase to the jury before taking it out of the courtroom due to the smell. The witness points out a broken handle to the jury.
- Gannon's remains, two blankets, and a pillow were all inside the suitcase.
- Prosecution asks Smith about the various bridges in the area. The Escambia River Bridge is a less traveled bridge than the others.
No cross examination. Jurors have questions:
- Was the suitcase cleaned? It appears cleaner: No, it was hard to see through the plastic.
- You visited the discovery site on March 17 2020 and the autopsy was on March 18 2020. You already knew on March 18 2020 that it was Gannon?: Not for sure. It was a tentative. They went by some pictures and then had to do followup identification. A finalized identification came later.